Another amusing point is that when looking at Ag subsidies, they are easily able to see - it's their first point - that Richer countries spend more on agricultural subsidies than poorer countries, even when seen relative to total agricultural production. But when looking at FF direct subsidies, they are unable to say anything about what kind of countries subsidise more. Could that be because when you look, the answer is that its the banana republics, not the West, doing the subsidising? There is a sliver of good news though: Implicit subsidies for fossil fuels... the local impacts of air pollution and global climate change constituting more than 75 percent of the total: so the banana republics are damaging themselves mostly, rather than us. This means that recommendations like Policy makers must fully reflect the health and societal costs of air pollution in the price of fossil fuels are dubious; because most of the damage / implicit subsidy occurs in what you burn and how you burn it, not how much you burn (see e.g. box 2.3). Indeed I'm somewhat dubious that their focus on FF is correct; they need to include "dung".
Perhaps I should note that I'm all for removing harmful subsidies. But I'm doubtful that a somewhat meally-mouthed report that can't bring itself to be honest about who is doing the subsidising, and which sez stuff like Subsidies are important tools that governments can use, is going to help.
Incidentally: I don't think they include negative subsidies (e.g. the EU's ETS) in their totals, and probably should.
Refs
* In Debate Over Railway Safety Bill, J.D. Vance and Donald Trump Are Leaning to the Left
* ‘Power and Progress’ Review: Technology and the New Leviathan: Deirdre N. McCloskey on Daron Acemoglu and Simon Johnson.
* Orwell’s Falsified Prediction on Empire.
* Diversity Really is Our Strength.
* OECD: Fossil fuel subsidies added up to at least $373bn in 2015?
* BBC More or Less: Behind the Stats: Do fossil fuels get $7 trillion in subsidies? The answer of course is no.
No comments:
Post a Comment